Financial details of Shell's (SHEL.L), opens new tab vast oil and gas trading business are some of the company's closest-held secrets. Documents in a lawsuit filed by a former employee, however, revealed its U.S. crude trading regularly earns around $1 billion every year.
Testimony by a former head of Shell's U.S. crude trading division filed in a Texas state court has offered a rare look at the huge profits of its trading operations and the multi-million dollar bonuses bestowed on traders.
John Dimech, who was a manager in Shell's crude oil trading group in Houston for 11 years, said in a deposition last year that the crude trading unit typically made between $950 million to $1 billion a year.
That is between 13% and 15% of Shell's overall U.S. pre-tax profits in recent years, according to calculations based on company filings.
Shell's 2022 tax contribution report detailed a pre-tax profit of just over $7 billion total in the U.S. that year, while its 2021 pretax profit stood at about $6.36 billion.
A Shell spokesperson declined to comment.
The British oil major does not disclose the financial performance of its oil and gas trading desk, the world's largest, although the lack of information worries some investors. The business can generate bumper profits, but can be volatile and even post losses.
Traders make money by buying and selling oil and gas using gaps in supply and demand around the world to lock in profits. Their pay often includes promises of large bonuses based on their performance, that can be more than CEO Wael Sawan's annual bonus, which was 2.7 million pounds ($3.4 million) last year, according to the latest annual report.
In the Houston court filing, Shell denied a breach of contract claim by former trading manager Eva-Maria Frohn, who sought $15 million, including $6 million for 2021's bonus. She received a more than $5 million bonus in 2020 for her work the previous year.
Frohn claimed that a job transfer she was offered would not be as lucrative as the job she held, making her redundant, while Shell maintained that her job rejection amounted to a resignation.
A jury last Tuesday rendered a verdict favorable to Shell, nullifying Frohn's entire claim against Shell, according, opens new tab to the law firm that represented the company.
Frohn's attorney did not reply to a request for comment.
